A former Gresham choir teacher was sentenced Tuesday to a total of eight years in prison and 10 years extended supervision on 62 counts of child porn possession, sex assault and child enticement.
Timothy J. Schmidt, 71, of Birnamwood, pleaded no contest to those charges in October.
Schmidt was originally charged in April 2017 with 24 felony counts, including sexual assault of a student and 19 counts of possession of child pornography.
He has been in jail since then and will be given credit for the nearly two years he has already served.
Schmidt was charged in July of last year with an additional 91 counts of possessing child porn. Some of the charges were dismissed under the plea agreement.
Schmidt, who had a one-year contract with the Gresham School District, resigned in April 2017 amid a police investigation that led to his arrest.
The investigation began in March 2017 when Stockbridge-Munsee police met with a parent of a Gresham Community School student reporting suspicious activity between Schmidt and her 16-year-old daughter.
The activity allegedly stretched back to October 2016.
The investigation revealed emails between Schmidt and the student that included discussion of sexual contact, according to the criminal complaint, as well exchanges of nude photos.
Schmidt denied in court Tuesday that nude images were exchanged.
The girl also told police about alleged sexual encounters with Schmidt and gifts he had given her, some of which were sexual in nature and which she found “embarrassing,” according to the complaint.
Shawano-Menominee County District Attorney Greg Parker told the court that the incidents continue to affect the victim’s life, including being forced to change schools because of bullying by other classmates.
“There is a great deal of emotional trauma to this young lady,” he said.
Parker read a statement from the girl’s mother in which she said, “these years that should have been filled with fun and excitement and new experiences were literally robbed from her because of Mr. Schmidt.”
Parker said the psycho-sexual evaluation of Schmidt showed he had a “pedophillic disorder” and that he had a penchant for prepubescent children judging by the volume of images found on his computer showing children as young as 3-5 years old in sexual poses or engaged in sexual activity.
The Shawano County Sheriff’s Department performed forensic examinations of computer devices belonging to Schmidt to determine whether sexual photos had been exchanged with the 16-year-old girl, according to the complaint.
The examination turned up more than 1,000 images of suspected child pornography.
Schmidt’s attorney, Jeremey Campshure, said the images of younger children were downloaded while Schmidt was searching for images of older children and that those images were deleted.
Campshure also said the photos exchanged between Schmidt and the girl had been “exaggerated” and did not constitute child pornography.
“The pictures they exchanged mostly involved clothing in some degree,” he said.
Campshure also said his client felt sympathy for and was protective of the girl and made the mistake of allowing that to blossom into a romance that clouded his judgment.
Schmidt, in a 20-minute statement to the court, disputed the state’s characterization of some of his behavior and said some of the incidents alleged by Parker were not true.
About 10 minutes into his statement, Schmidt took responsibility for his actions with the girl.
“I’m accountable for allowing that friendship and compassion to go farther,” he said. “There were numerous times when I could have changed the course of events, but I failed to do so.”
Schmidt broke into tears as he told the court he was sorry for hurting the girl and his family.
Schmidt then turned to criticizing the news media for the way it has “sensationalized” the story.
He said the photos exchanged with the girl contained nothing graphic, lewd or pornographic.
“The continued reporting of these words, ‘exchanging nude pictures,’ was slanderous and defaming to both of us,” he said.
Schmidt also defended a Christmas letter he sent to the girl from jail in violation of a prohibition against his contacting the victim.
The letter included multiple biblical verses.
“My own devastation of losing so much was helped only by my returning to God and scripture,” Schmidt said. “This was made clear to her in the letter, and the scriptures I selected all discuss how God was the protector, defender and provider to those who seek him.”
Schmidt sobbed again as he talked about his child porn collection and how his efforts to educate children had been his true passion all his life.
“I don’t understand why I did what I did,” he said. “I have no idea where my interest in such debauchery comes from. All I know is that I recently have struggled with it. I sincerely apologize to all my acquaintances for disappointing them. A man can be embarrassed no lower than I am today.”
Langlade County Judge John Rhode, who heard the case after Schmidt’s request for a judicial substitution, said he saw some genuine remorse from Schmidt and some acceptance of responsibility for his actions.
“I would like to have seen more,” he said, adding that Schmidt still apparently sees a need to explain and justify his actions.
Rhode called Schmidt “his own worst enemy” and chastised him for repeatedly interrupting Parker’s sentencing argument with denials during the hearing.
Rhode said Schmidt had “unnatural sexual attractions” and noted that the distribution of child pornography continues to re-victimize the children involved every time it’s viewed.
He said prison time for Schmidt would send a message of deterrence for other who might want to view child porn.
Schmidt was given three years in prison and three years extended supervision on each of the 62 counts of possessing child porn, all running concurrently.
He was also given the same sentence on the charge of sexual assault of a student by school staff.
His heaviest sentence, running concurrently with the others, was eight years in prison and 10 years extended supervision on the charge of child enticement-sexual contact.